Late last week, the Mississippi Supreme Court issued a ruling on a case that has captured the attention of lawmakers and media alike.
The case involved $10 million in a legislative appropriation that was directed to the Independent Schools Infrastructure Grant Program, which was designed to provide financial relief to private schools for infrastructure improvements in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. The program was funded by the state legislature using funds made available by the federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA).
In June 2022, a nonprofit organization, Parents for Public Schools, challenged the constitutionality of the program, specifically that the program violated article 8, section 208 of the Mississippi Constitution. The Mississippi Supreme Court determined that Parents for Public Schools did not have standing to bring the lawsuit, vacating an earlier ruling by the Hinds County Chancery Court.
While some have misconstrued the case as a challenge to the constitutionality of private education choice programs in the Magnolia State, such as ESAs or vouchers, the case was never about those programs at all. Rather, this case was specifically related to the direct appropriation of ARPA funds to private schools in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. Mississippi, in fact, has had 3 private education choice programs in existence for years, none of which have ever been challenged in the courts.
We contend that private education choice policies are indeed constitutional in Mississippi, a fact that is not disputed in the ruling issued by the Supreme Court. David Hodges of the Institute for Justice and Aaron Rice of the Mississippi Justice Institute explained this position in an amicus brief submitted for this case:
“First, the Mississippi Constitution permits the legislature to provide financial aid to students that they can then use for nonpublic goods and services, including tuition at nonpublic schools. Thus, even if Mississippi bars public funds from being appropriated directly to nonpublic schools, that bar does not encompass programs that provide aid to students who may use that aid to procure a nonpublic education.
Read original article by clicking here.